Would anyone want Anna back?

greenspun.com : LUSENET : ER Discussions : One Thread

Another question from me...I know that this would be way too much of a coincidence for Anna to return just in time to come to Carter's emotional rescue, but I think it would be nice. I will always prefer Lucy to any other girl in Carter's life (no matter what aspect), but I liked Carter when he was around Anna, and he would maybe open up to her like no one else. And she fit into the cast well, esp. during the girls' night with Carol and Elizabeth. Anyone else agree or disagree?

-- Elaine (mrsclooney78@hotmail.com), March 28, 2000


I liked Anna. Maybe because I really started to get into ER during the third season, I don't know. But I did like them together a lot and hate how she just disappeared. Carter and Lucy bugged me. I doubt they will bring Anna back, though I do think it would be nice. Not to console Carter, just to have her back. Wishful thinking. Apparently, TPTB don't like us to have too many characters we actually know something about.

-- Carly (Butrcup583@aol.com), March 28, 2000.

I loved Anna and Carter's interaction...like Carol and Doug and Susan and Mark, they had a long buildup. Unfortunately, the buildup never amounted to anything since Maria left the show...but that's another gripe. I would love to see her come back for him, but in considering this possibility I can't help but think of when Mark was attacked. It happened the same season Susan left, and I wanted so incredibly badly for her to come back to visit him, or call, or something to show support. In scenes where Mark was alone and obviously struggling with emotional/physical issues, I wanted him to say, "Jeez, Susan, I miss you more than I can stand..." or some such thing. I guess since Carter seems so alone now I'd like at least a mention of missing her (they were great buddies despite Carter's romantic intentions). And if she were to come back, it would add an interesting dimension to the possibility of his painkiller storyline (her supposed drug use, Max Rosher's addiction, etc). I'm not too hopefull that it's actually going to happen, though.

-- nancy (ntc72@mailcity.com), March 28, 2000.

I was never a great fan of Anna, and I didn't really enjoy the prospect of Anna and Carter a lot (I thought they were boring), but the way things are going I would take Anna over any of the newer characters. I wish the writers would put in more girls night outs. The characters never seem to socialize together anymore.

-- Emma (webbef@hotmail.com), March 28, 2000.

Anna was about as dull as Dr. Finch. ZZZZZZZ

-- Rachel (Rachel_L_Stephens@prodigy.net), March 29, 2000.

I like the girls' night out concept, too ... remember that epi where Elizabeth, Carol and Anna were hanging out at Elizabeth's place and Benton came by? That was just priceless the way Anna and Carol crowded in next to Elizabeth at the door! It would be nice to see more of the "bonding" that we used to see between Mark & Doug, Mark & Susan, Anna & Carter, etc.

-- Cindy (tailchasers51@hotmail.com), March 29, 2000.

Hallo Elaine! This now this the first time I'm at this website and just surf. I come from Germany and here we can see the 5th season now. Lucy is still alive. I would really enjoy a comeback of Anna. I think she was a very good charakter. I miss her. First because of her "realationship" with Carter and also because she was such a good and nice person. It would be so great when she return one day!!! If you want, write an EMail to me. I will be thankful!!!

-- Sarah (TWeinberger@t-online.de), April 12, 2000.

Moderation questions? read the FAQ