Use of FD Bellows: EOS or FD system best?

greenspun.com : LUSENET : Canon EOS FAQ forum : One Thread

I have an EOS3 with some lenses (no macro) and an A-1 with standard lens. I have recently acquired a Canon FD bellows unit plus slide duplicator and would like to use it to make negatives from my slides to print (this is not critical work, since I usulally do this through a large format internegative, but I would like reasonable quality).

I have two questions:

1. Is there any advantage in using the EOS equipment for this purpose? I do not have the macro adaptor to fit EOS body to bellows at present)and unless EOS system gives me definite advantage I would prefer to use FD system..

2. What is the best light source, flash (I have several speedlites) or natural light. If flash, how do I calculate the exposure?

Thanks in advance for your help.

-- enrique munoz (enrike@rocketmail.com), April 09, 1999

Answers

Enrique, you asked about a possible advantage of the EOS system over FD. Since you're interested in macro photography, there is in fact one huge advantage: Your EOS gives you TTL flash control, your A-1 won't. Flash is *the* light source for close-up and macro photography, and TTL flash is a godsent gift for this application. Get a TTL extension cord for your flash, set the desired aperture and let the camera do the rest. No need to calculate exposure. A combination of ambient daylight and fill flash also looks very nice and natural.

BTW: A bellows is fine for higher magnifications (exceeding 1x or life size), but for everything else I'd recommend a good macro lens. Using a 50 mm standard lens on your bellows is a compromise. These lenses simply are not designed for high magnification work. However, at least the center should be rendered with sufficient sharpness. You should also think about using the lens reversed. Finally: How about an enlarging lens? These lenses are much better macro optics than every standard lens that's optimized for 'infinity'.

However, if you're still interested in how to use flash manually (maybe in order to find out the limits for automatic TTL flash) I recommend John Shaw's "Closeups in Nature".

Dieter

-- Dieter (lefeling@icsmedia.de), April 10, 1999.


Moderation questions? read the FAQ