Lila Lake(s)

greenspun.com : LUSENET : Nature Photography Image Critique : One Thread

http://www.bigadventures.com/hiking/12

-- Steve Leroux (steve@bigadventures.com), September 01, 1998

Answers


On my way to Alta Mountain, near Snoqualmie Pass in Washington State, USA. Pentax ZX5n; Sigma 24/2.8; Royal Gold 25.
More photos and the story behind the hike can be found at http://www.bigadventures.com/hiking/12

-- Steve Leroux (steve@bigadventures.com), September 01, 1998.

The landscape looks nice, but the lighting seems to be very flat. Was this picture taken around noon time?

-- Shun Cheung (shun@worldnet.att.net), September 01, 1998.

My guess it that this was taken within 2 hours of midday judging by the shadows. More sidelighing (ie. earliar or later) would have improved the shot. I do not like the rock ledge in the forground. Why not have something interesting there? Perhaps a closer view of one of the pines. Maybe a through the branches sort of framing. The landscape is very beautiful however the bland foreground rock ledge just takes too much away from this shot for my taste.

-- Paul Lenson (lenson@pci.on.ca), September 01, 1998.

This image would need some really extraordinary lighting to make it interesting as a picture. There are millions of photos like this done each year and there is nothing in this one to set it apart from the rest.

Frank

-- Frank Kolwicz (bb389@lafn.org), September 01, 1998.


Steve-with all due respect to Franks comment about this image and it's "commoness", it is YOUR image. Enjoy it and be proud of it. I like it for the subject and composition, but it would have been more dramatic during the golden hours. I prefer a.m. light to p.m. pesonally. Otherwise it is a beautiful image. I have yet to make one like it. Then again, I'm just an amateur.

-- Jim Korczak (korczaks@ptdprolog.net), September 01, 1998.


When I take this type of photo, I an usually disappointed. To capture the beauty of detailed lanscape scene seems, at least to me, to beg for a 4X5. To cut to the chase, the Web is a poor format for this type of scene. So this isn't a criticism of the photo but a question as to choice of type of image.

-- Warren Kato (wkato@aol.com), September 02, 1998.

I doubt that this photo wold look any more interesting if it had been taken with a 4x5 camera. Here we have one of the "paradoxes of photography": I am sure the scene was very impressive as you stood there, especially after a long climb/hike. Reduced to a two dimensional sheet of paper it looses so much that as a photograph it becomes uninteresting for those who haven't been there.

-- (andreas@physio.unr.edu), September 03, 1998.

Moderation questions? read the FAQ